Docs

Integrity pre-screening for journals

Status

This is a pilot, and it is not live. The service is written and tested, but it isn't deployed anywhere, and there is no data-processing agreement for it yet. Don't send manuscripts until both exist. See the evidence.

What it is

Other journals will be able to run the same integrity checks that every WOISPO submission goes through, on their own manuscripts. A journal sends a manuscript (PDF, plain text or Markdown) with its reference list, title, abstract and keywords. The service returns findings:

  • Instructions aimed at AI reviewers, in the text, the metadata, HTML comments, alt text and the reference list, including disguised ones (invisible characters, look-alike letters, encoded text). Each finding says where it is.
  • Hidden text in PDFs. This is text a reader can't see: invisible, near-transparent, coloured like its background, under 2 pt, off the page, under a shape or in a hidden layer. Each finding gives its page.
  • References. Every reference is looked up in Crossref and OpenAlex. Each one comes back as resolved, unresolved, or a mismatch (its DOI belongs to a different work).
  • An overall level (none, low, medium or high), with the same thresholds as WOISPO's own screen.

What it is not

It is not peer review. It makes no judgement of a manuscript's quality, novelty, methods or correctness, and it writes no review. Every check is rule-based: no language model reads the manuscript. DOAJ guidance and most publishers' AI policies rule out AI-written peer review, and this service doesn't offer it. A finding is a reason for an editor to look, not a verdict on the authors.

Re-running authors' code is not offered. It needs the isolated verification host, which doesn't exist yet (see Verification levels).

How manuscripts are handled

These are the rules the service is built to. The data-processing agreement will have to match them.

  • The manuscript is held in memory while it is screened and is never written to disk. When the screen ends, it is discarded.
  • The result is kept for 7 days by default (configurable, at most 90), then deleted. The journal can delete it at any time. The result holds the reference list and short quotes (at most 200 characters) around each finding.
  • The only data that leaves the service is reference lookups. For each reference, Crossref gets the DOI, or OpenAlex gets a title taken from that reference. Body text, title, abstract and keywords are never sent anywhere. Over-long "references" are not sent at all.
  • PDFs are read by a text-extraction server (GROBID) that runs inside the same private network and contacts nobody.
  • Each journal gets its own API key. WOISPO stores only a hash of it. Each key has its own rate limit and size limit. A journal can see only its own results.

What it costs

Nothing is charged during the pilot. Pricing will be set by contract; see Pricing.